Listed below are former Atlanta Youth Lacrosse players who have received Academic All-American, All-American, All-State and All-League recognition:
Academic All-Americans 2000 to 2010
- Matt, Garcia – Midfield (Pace Academy)
- Matt, Smentek - Goalie (North Springs)
- Pirrung, Kiefer — Midfield (Atlanta, GA/Pace Academy, GA)
- Heller, Jamie — (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA)
- Morris, Eric — Attack (Marietta, GA/Pope, GA)
- Schwartz, Bill — Attack (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA) — Virginia
- Fischer, Taylor — (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA)
- Hartwell, Hunter — Midfield (Norcross, GA/Wesleyan, GA)
All-Americans 2000 to 2010
- Brent, Holloway (Atlanta, GA/Pope)
- Wat, Bryant – Attack (Atlanta, GA/Westminster)
- Kevin, Magyar – Midfield (Duluth, GA/Chattahoochee)
- Andy, Lochridge – Defensive Midfield (Atlanta, GA/Westminster)
- Love, Dennis — Attack (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA)
- Cohen, Andrew — Goalie (Atlanta, GA/Pope, GA) — (senior)
- Durkee, Foster — Defense (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA) — (senior)
- Cranshaw, Matt — Attack (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA) — Williams
- Lukens, Davis — Attack (Atlanta, GA/Holy Innocents Episcopal, GA) — (junior)
- Rhodes, Nick — Midfield (Atlanta, GA/Pace Academy, GA) — (junior)
- Lukens, Davis — Attack (Marietta, GA/Holy Innocents Episcopal, GA) — Denison
- Rhodes, Nick — Midfield (Atlanta, GA/Pace Academy, GA) — Penn
- Seiler, Stuart — Defense (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA) — Georgia
- Soto, Eric — Defense (Marietta, GA/Pope, GA) — Massachusetts
- Bowling, Darius — Defense (Atlanta, GA/Holy Innocents, GA) — (junior)
- Green, Owen — Attack (Atlanta, GA/Lovett, GA) — Jacksonville
- Ratliff, Scott — Defense/LSM (Marietta, GA/Walton, GA) — Loyola
- Green, Owen — Attack (Atlanta, GA/Lovett, GA) — Jacksonville
- Winship, North — Midfield (Atlanta, GA/Lovett, GA) — North Carolina
- Bowling, Darius — Defense (Atlanta, GA/Holy Innocents, GA) — Ohio State
- Izlar, Jimbo — Attack (Atlanta, GA/Westminster, GA) — (junior)
All-State 2005
- Dennis Love-Westminster School
- Kiefer Pirrung-Pace Academy
- Patrick Battey-Westminster School
- David Sibley-Lovett School
- Jeff Allen-Wesleyan School
- Alex Heaton-Lovett School
- Henry McAlpin-Pace Academy
- Hammond McEver-Lovett School
- Foster Durkee-Westminster School
- Andrew Garcia-Pace Academy
- Brant Evans-North Springs High School
- Graham Dozier-Lovett School
- David Perrin-Westminster School
- Sam Cook- Woodward Academy
- Andrew Cohen-Pope High School
All-League 2005
- James McClintock-Riverwood High School
- Patrick Murphy-St. Pius High School
- Tom Hayford-Blessed Trinity High School
- Scott Singer-St. Pius High School
- Colin Hughes-Holy Innocents Episcopal School
- Glenn Dorris-Westminster School
- Rick Patillo-Woodward Academy
- Blake Kilday-Woodstock High School
- Stuart Lawder-Wesleyan School
All-State 2006
- Mac Williams-Westminster
- Scott Singer-St. Pius
- Jay Perrett-Lovett
- Foster Durkee-Westminster
- Andrew Cohen-Pope
- David Perrin-Westminster
- Davis Lukens-HIES
- Gordon Wyche-Pace Academy
- Mshon Pulliam-Woodward
- Matt Cranshaw-Westminster
- Wade Askew-Westminster
- Gordon Corsetti-Pace Academy
- Brad Cain-Lovett
- Andrew Witt-Walton
- Nick Rhodes-Pace Academy
- Philip Georgakakos-HIES
- Justin Leef-Pace Academy
- Carson McLean-Woodward
- Witt Harlin-Walton
- Andy Head-Lovett
- Dan Crabtree-Walton
- Logan Novak-Walton
All-League 2006
- David Maxwell-Woodward
- Chase Thomas-Walton
- Kevin Dolezal-Westminster
- Cason Milner-Woodward
- Will Rowe-Centennial
All-State 2007
- Matt Cranshaw – The Westminster Schools
- Davis Lukens – Holy Innocents
- Nick Rhodes – Pace Academy
- Andy Head – Lovett School
- Kevin Dolezal – The Westminster Schools
- Tommy Noonan – The Westminster Schools
- Taylor Howard – The Westminster Schools
- Perrin Williams – Lovett School
- Michael Kress – Wesleyan School
- Defense
- Eric Soto – Pope High School
- Philip Georgakakos – Holy Innocents
- Patrick Luckhurst – Wesleyan School
- Fraser Perrett – Lovett
- Owen Green – Lovett School
- Scott Dockery – Pope High School
- Taylor King – St. Pius X
- Darius Bowling – Holy Innocents
- Justin Leef – Pace Academy
- Jake Harris – Pace Academy
- Zach Tenuta – Walton High School
- Stuart Haddow – Holy Innocents
- North Winship – Lovett School
- Chase Thomas – Walton High School
All-League 2007
- Kit York – Holy Innocents
- Stuart Seiler – The Westminster Schools
- Eric Alessi – Walton High School
All-State 2008
- Davis Lukens-HIES
- Owen Green-Lovett School
- Scott Dockery-Pope High School
- Eric Soto-Pope High School
- Stuart Seiler-Westminster School
- Philip Georgakakos-HIES
- Zach Tenuta-Walton High School
- Scott Dunlevie-Westminster School
- North Winship-Lovett School
- Thomas Bowman-Pace Academy
- Nick Stonecipher-Lovett School
- Fraser Perrett-Lovett School
- Justin Leef-Pace Academy
- Philip Costas-St. Pius
- Lee Hendee-St. Pius High School
- Scott Ratliff-Walton High School
- Perrin Williams-Lovett School
- Tommy Noonan-Westminster School
- Kit York-HIES
- Josh Roach-Woodward Academy
- Chase Thomas-Walton High School
- Darius Bowling-HIES
- Drew Bigalow-Wesleyan School
- Tim Coates-Woodward Academy
- Jack Stoors-St. Pius
- Brian Garber-HIES
All-League 2008
- Bobby Fulton-Wesleyan School
- Wesley Kinney-Woodward Academy
All-State 2009
- Lovett – Owen Green
- Lovett – North Winship
- Milton – Kevin Reed
- Walton – Ross Lenenski
- Wesleyan – Drew Bigalow (Long Stick Midfield)
- Holy Innocents – Darius Bowling
- Walton – Scott Ratliff
- Wesleyan – Davis Brown
- Westminster – Scott Dunlevie
- Wesleyan – Bobby Fulton
- Lovett – Perrin Williams
- Lovett – Austin Heaton
- Lovett – Stuart Dodd
- Pope – Jack Morris
- Westminster – Chris Reagan (Long Stick Midfield)
- Holy Innocents – Connor Randall
- Holy Innocents – Eric Wypyski
- Riverwood – Camp Schweers
All-League 2009
- Westminster – Jimbo Izlar
- Holy Innocents – John Mitchell
- Pace Academy – Matt Hickey
- Pace Academy – Thomas Bowman
All-State 2010
- Attack – Jimbo Izlar – Westminster
- Defense – Darius Bowling – Holy Innocents
- Defense – Isaac Seals – Decatur
- Attack – Davis Brown – Wesleyan
- Midfield – Chase Brown – Holy Innocents
- Defense – Jordan Miller – Holy Innocents
